Scores and Comments

25.c.pr.800.422

Kirk Whipple

Application Details

Proposal TypeSpecific Cultural Project - Individual Artist
Request Amount
$25,000
Total Score433.000
Average Score86.600

Panelist Scores

Panelist Quality of Offerings Impact Track Record History and Heritage Total
Fisher Naomi 32 30 27 0 89
Jean Edson 30 28 30 0 88
Kalin Betsy 28 28 24 0 80
Kehoe Katie 30 30 30 0 90
Ponce Libbi 30 26 30 0 86

Comments

Fisher Naomi - Score: 89.000

Quality of Offerings: 32

-Professional testaments as letters of support

-Solid music samples

-Nice brochures from past presentations

Impact: 30

-Doing a kickstarter campaign

-marketing and promotion partners

-concert goers economic impact for local businesses

Track Record: 27

-4 letters of support 

-Lifelong relationships with educators and presenters

-Many past organizational partners cited

-Support seemed more within professional circles, hard to tell what external validation has happened

-Past Recipient of CBF 

Jean Edson - Score: 88.000
{No comments provided.}
Kalin Betsy - Score: 80.000
{No comments provided.}
Kehoe Katie - Score: 90.000

- Description, goals, objectives and project activities are clearly articulated. Could be more specific as to what tangible actions will be taken to evaluate success – attendance? Critical reviews? Etc. Great that he has named collaborators and confirmed partners.

 

- In Impact / reach section he states there will be three events related to this project; however earlier he states there will be 8 to 10 live concerts. Very detailed response to question 14 part b.  (also Good that he detailed his experience with education and outreach through partner orgs.)

- With respect to the budget, given the artist has created the pieces and is proposing this project to perform and record them the fee they have assigned to themselves, seems to be high.

Ponce Libbi - Score: 86.000
{No comments provided.}