Scores and Comments

25.c.pr.800.730

Kristin Guerin

Application Details

Proposal TypeSpecific Cultural Project - Individual Artist
Request Amount
$25,000
Total Score424.000
Average Score84.800

Panelist Scores

Panelist Quality of Offerings Impact Track Record History and Heritage Total
Fisher Naomi 25 30 25 0 80
Jean Edson 30 30 27 0 87
Kalin Betsy 29 30 27 0 86
Kehoe Katie 30 30 30 0 90
Ponce Libbi 27 27 27 0 81

Comments

Fisher Naomi - Score: 80.000

(UPDATE: Score to 80 based on updates)

Quality of Offerings: 24

-unclear in the reel what was her own work, work shown was fair to good

-Constellation Healing as theater for immigration trauma, but no clear evidence of training to deal with trauma or having worked with immigrants in the past

(UPDATE: Licenced Constellation therapist participating and offering $10 reduced fee therapy sessions for participants)

 

Impact: 24

-Cash match from ticket sales is listed at $300,000, and attendance is listed at 300 people at 10 shows. This means, ticket prices are $100 each and assuming sold out shows. This is not an accessible ticket price.

(UPDATE: Typo, month long run)

-Lists immigrants as target audience without clear explanation of why other than trauma, nor how outreach would happen to reach target audience 

(UPDATE: More than half fridge program recipients in a program she runs are facing immigration justice, advertising would take place within this program.)

 

Track Record: 25

-Fractured Atlas is a fiscal sponsor

-In the pandemic, Co-founded and runs an ongoing community fridge project

But:

-many producer credits, but resume and cv was unclear about which projects I was seeing was her own work

-no letters of support

-no confirmed venues or collaborators

Jean Edson - Score: 87.000
{No comments provided.}
Kalin Betsy - Score: 86.000
{No comments provided.}
Kehoe Katie - Score: 90.000

Project description is communicated clearly. Application could be strengthened if goals, objectives and project activities were expanded upon as well if names of collaborators were listed, along with some info provided as to their qualifications.

With respect to the budget, it looks like the cash match is deriving primarily from ticket sales, however the target audience is immigrants who have experience trauma, I am concerned that ticket costs will present a barrier to access.


Ponce Libbi - Score: 81.000
Please include dates in resume activities.