Scores and Comments

25.c.pr.800.772

Haiqiong Deng

Application Details

Proposal TypeSpecific Cultural Project - Individual Artist
Request Amount
$20,000
Total Score469.000
Average Score93.800

Panelist Scores

Panelist Quality of Offerings Impact Track Record History and Heritage Total
Fisher Naomi 35 35 29 0 99
Jean Edson 32 30 30 0 92
Kalin Betsy 35 35 30 0 100
Kehoe Katie 32 32 30 0 94
Ponce Libbi 27 27 30 0 84

Comments

Fisher Naomi - Score: 99.000

Quality of Offerings: 35

-Scholarly work for 3 decade, with a recent PhD

-adapting her instrument of study to perform with a wide range of other cultures as seen in videos in support material: performances with Indian Sitar and also Southern Country string quartet

 

 

Impact: 35

-Furthering these multicultural collaborations that initial phases already received massive views and a review is an excellent way to create connections between traditionally Southern Bluegrass music and Chinese music.

 

 

Track Record: 29

-traction from past projects 

-extensive profession CV

-No letters of support or specific venues or music companies - however - much of this is for producing videos for social media so not needed

-track record of viral bluegrass social media video  

Jean Edson - Score: 92.000
{No comments provided.}
Kalin Betsy - Score: 100.000
{No comments provided.}
Kehoe Katie - Score: 94.000

Project description, goals and objective clearly identified; project activities could be strengthened with more detail.

Having identified specific venues where these presentations would take place could strengthen the application and help to convey expanded impact, with respect to both reach and access. 

The budget conveys as modest in that it is supporting three projects all under the umbrella of raising awareness for the cultural diversity of Tallahassee creative community.

Work samples convey the three collaborative endeavors outlined in the grant application. Music is particularly strong.

Ponce Libbi - Score: 84.000
Visual Art samples are not particularly exceptionary, but benefits from presentation with music.